Devotional Intimacy Loneliness Miscellaneous Random Ponderings theology

Is it okay if I don’t ‘feel’ God?

Theology takes her time building up to an emotional crescendo. It may take years but it is so worth it.


Yesterday at the gym, I started talking with a college student.

“I’m pretty sure you spoke at my school’s chapel, right?” he asked. I said yes, and we fell into some theological dialogue. After a minute or two, I could tell that his pressing question was rising to the surface.

“So, I guess the thing I keep coming back to is, everyone else seems to feel God, whether they’re feeling His presence, or they just have some emotion which I’ve never had.”

He impressed me by quoting Pascal’s Wager, which states that logically, the believer is safer than the atheist, and that was one of the driving forces in his faith. He reminded me of the Bereans in Acts, who were constantly searching the Scriptures to test the things the apostles were teaching them about Jesus.

I told him, “I feel ancient saying this, but you honestly remind me of myself when I was your age.” I told him I was with a mission organization where it seemed that EVERYONE was FEELING God constantly, yet I never seemed to have the same experience.

I even knew one guy who told me he would listen to sad music or watch a sad movie before every worship service he went to ‘in order to soften my heart.’ It seemed an awful lot like a ploy to make him cry and supposedly have a more authentic experience with God…despite the fact that what he was crying about wasn’t necessarily God-related…

The problem for me when I was with this organization was that I never felt any emotion about those things. I never teared up when I thought about the gospel, nor could I recount any specific episodes of ‘feeling the presence of God.’ I feared that something was wrong with me, and I wasn’t really a Christian since I wasn’t having these monumental experiences.

I didn’t cry for over four years.

Then one day at church, I did. And a month or two after that, I did again. And I wouldn’t say I’m quite at the Jude-Law-in-The-Holiday-level yet, but I have found that my emotion toward God expands the more I learn about Him. This post is a piggyback on a previous one on the dumbing down of Christianity, in which I discussed a fear Christians tend to have regarding intellectual theology and learning about God and the Bible. I can’t help but think that we have replaced those things with emotion and awe-inspiring performances at our (larger) churches. Theology often isn’t sexy.

I don’t want to make this comment as a rule, but couldn’t we draw parallels between “emotional-pull churches” and one night stands? We want the emotional high without putting in the time to build up to a real and meaningful relationship; we want a shortcut to ecstasy. The man in the bar who wants sex with a stranger wants the feelings of intimacy without the patience and work.

Theology also takes her time to build up to an emotional crescendo.

Or at least, that’s been my experience. I could have tried to squeeze the tears out all those years ago, and I did try, but they would have been false tears. What I have found is that my emotion has followed truth. The more I learn, the more I feel in regard to Jesus and His relevance in my life.

Even this morning, the pastor preached a sermon on the importance of good theology. He said, “Years ago, I only knew that much about God and therefore, I could only worship that much of Him. But over years of study, my knowledge of Him has grown to this much and I can now worship this much more of Him!” Just as in a dating relationship, the more you learn about the other person, the more you are able to fully love and experience them as they are. You wouldn’t want to remain ignorant and superficial in a marriage, but why would you in your relationship with Christ?

So what I told the kid at the gym was just that: Let your heart follow your head. You’re in a good place, and the emotion will come when the time is right. Don’t force it and don’t think you’re broken if you don’t feel the way everyone else does. In fact, I would argue that there is danger in being led spiritually by your emotions.

Of course, a good balance is necessary, but like I said in the Dumbing Down article, I see most Americans swinging far toward emotion and experience more than knowledge and truth. The whole notion of having a magnificent emotional rollercoaster of a worship service is very new to the Christian faith, emerging in the past couple hundred years. Does that mean that for the first 1,700 years of her existence, the Church was doing it wrong? Or maybe it’s we who are a little off-track.

Do you not feel God? You’re not alone. Many heroes of the faith felt very distant from God most of their lives, including the author of most of the Psalms, King David. He wrote, “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” Words which would be repeated by Jesus as He withered on the cross.

The best advice I can give is to keep learning about God. Keep reading the Word and filling your mind with Him. The act of these disciplines will eventually reorient your desires toward Him, and even though they are not glamorous or even fun, your emotions will follow.

“The ruts of routine become the grooves of grace.”

The things you fill your head with will eventually trickle down into your heart; your emotions will be affected by what you put in your mind. There’s no way they can’t be! So don’t try to rush it. I would argue that wisdom doesn’t attempt to conjure up a false emotional experience, but simply remains faithful and lets the emotion come when the time is right.

I have reached a place now where I use words like ‘kerygma’ and ‘ontology’ and get a little misty-eyed. I sit in theology classes and feel stones rise up in my throat because I’m engaging with the material at a much deeper place than I could have seven years ago.

Most of you are the opposite. I recognize that I’m an outlier here. Different views of our beautiful God will choke you up and tug on your heart, but one thing is true across the board: You won’t reach these deep places with Him if you’re not filling your mind with His words and orienting your life toward Him.

It will come in time.

So may we be people who pursue God, not an emotional high. May we be people who see God working in all areas of our lives, especially many of the mundane and unglamorous nooks. May we be comforted by knowing that He is not simply an emotion to be conjured up at will, but He is a person; a Father who wants to walk the journey of our lives with us. And that means that there will be a lot of long stretches of road without emotion or hype, just many, many trudging footsteps.


6 comments on “Is it okay if I don’t ‘feel’ God?

  1. Ethan, I really appreciate that you take the time to write posts like this. Every time I visit this site, I’m thankful I did. Your writing is brutally honest and filled with hope. Keep pressing on!

  2. Pascal’s Wager, not Occam’s Razor (which implies the oppposite).

    • Oh my gosh, you’re right. I literally listened to a podcast on Occam’s Razor last night so they were both fresh in my head! hahaha

  3. Yesterday I watched this film called The Reality of Truth. The title got me interested cause if we’re not dealing with reality, we’re just talking about things as topics. The film is about spiritual experiences you can have using meditation, breathing techniques and plant medicines, psychedelics. Assuming the film is honest, the experiences people had were transformative in their lives – long-standing harmful habits were broken, how they viewed themselves and others was radically transformed, inner turmoils ceased – they themselves viewed it as life-changing. They had genuine spiritual experiences but apart from Christ. To your point, we shouldn’t chase or rely on emotions or experiences to validate our faith.

    But I had another takeaway, there is the reality of genuine spiritual experience in Christ. One of the guys in the film who was deeply transformed opened a place in Costa Rica where you can go on retreat and experience these things. I checked out the website and the comments left on Yelp. There’s 80 pages of comments and only one 1 star review; other than a few 4 star, all the others are 5 star. People had what they viewed as spiritually transformative experiences that changed them. We believe in the reality of the living God dwelling within us by His Spirit, the Spirit of life and holiness and grace and glory as the NT says. We believe in union with Christ and the power of his resurrection and dwelling with him now. If these things are true, if they are real, there is an experience of that living reality in our lives. We shouldn’t pursue spiritual experiences, but if Jesus and God are just topics, we’re missing the reality.

  4. This is so good! I’m a very emotional person so I tend to experience God through emotions but as my relationship with the Lord has deepened those experiences are different. Often times the emotional experiences are out of truth that is revealed not just “feeling.” It’s a conversation that I have with my youth often, although God can and does meet us in the midst of our emotions, emotions aren’t always truth.

    I especially love that your own walk with God was able to bring truth to someone else. So cool!!

  5. Pingback: Is It Okay if I Don’t ‘Feel’ God?

Leave a Reply to ethanrenoeCancel reply

%d bloggers like this: